(15) THE "RESURRECTED" REPORT - THE EXPLOSIVE CIA REPORT THAT HAD QUOTED PHAN HIEN AS SAYING JUST PRIOR TO HIS TALKS IN HANOI WITH CARTER ENVOY LEONARD WOODCOCK DURING MARCH 1977 THAT THE SRV WAS STILL HOLDING AMERICAN POWS.
(See An Enormous Crime, Chapter 16)

During the spring of 1983, Hendon was reviewing intelligence files in his Pentagon office (See An Enormous Crime, Chapter 22) when he read for the first time the classified version of a CIA Field Intelligence Report (FIR) dated 16 March 1977 that quoted Indonesia’s ambassador to the SRV, Ambassador Hardi, as reporting to his government that Vietnamese Deputy Foreign Minister Phan Hien (pronounced Fon HEE un) and other SRV officials with whom he had had contact recently told him that the SRV continued to hold American POWs and that these POWs posed a problem to the opening of diplomatic relations between the SRV and the U.S. The source of the CIA report was described in the FIR as a "generally reliable source with excellent access to high-level Indonesian Government officials."

Given the solid sourcing and the critical nature of the intelligence and its timing—President Carter’s personal envoy Leonard Woodcock and members of his commission charged with determining the fate of the POWs and MIAs were in Hanoi for crucial, life-or-death talks with Phan Hien at the time—plus the fact that Woodcock had returned to the U.S. after his talks with Phan Hien and had immediately informed Carter that no POWs remained alive—had made Hendon wonder: what had Woodcock done with this remarkable and remarkably timed piece of intelligence? Had it influenced his strategy in his negotiations with Hien? Had he confronted Hien with it? If so, what had Hien said in reply? And with that crucial intelligence in his possession, how could he possibly have informed the president upon his return that no POWs remained alive?

In an effort to find out the answers to those and other questions, Hendon asked Special Office personnel for the complete working file on the CIA report. When his request was denied, he met with Charles Trowbridge, the Special Office’s Deputy Chief to ask about the report. The powerful, chronically-negative Trowbridge had worked at the Special Office during the war and since Operation Homecoming had served as its number two man. He and Hendon were oil and water—Trowbridge the secretive, "share-nothing" career bureaucrat; Hendon the outspoken young congressman who made no attempt to hide his contempt for what was going on at the Special Office. What had DIA done about this crucial intelligence? Hendon asked Trowbridge. Nothing, Trowbridge replied. What had DoD, State and/or CIA done about it? He didn’t know, Trowbridge said. Given its solid sourcing, remarkable contents and equally remarkable timing, this is a very explosive report, perhaps one of the most important pieces of intelligence received about living POWs in the entire postwar era; one surely worthy of congressional investigation, Hendon told Trowbridge. I’ll look into it and see what I can find out, Trowbridge said. 202

On 26 September 1983, several months after Hendon had resigned his position at the Pentagon and returned to North Carolina to attempt to reclaim his old congressional seat, CIA notified DIA and the other addressees of the original Hardi/Phan Hien 16 March 1977 FIR—which by now had been on the books for over six and one half years—that the FIR "has been determined to be a fabrication" and "the information in the memorandum should be disregarded and all references to the report should be removed from computer listings and file holdings." 203


everal hundred more reports like the 15 discussed above would be received throughout the 1980’s, the 1990’s and into the 21st century. Every one would be subjected to the same treatment as these 15; not one would be believed. Additionally, satellite imagery taken over northern Vietnam and northern Laos during the late 1980’s and early 1990’s would show USAF/USN escape and evasion codes and four-digit authenticators assigned to missing fliers - and the names of at least two missing Air Force officers – displayed along trails, in rice paddies or in fields. All would be declared "natural phenomena," "naturally occurring variations in soil," "naturally-occurring vegetation and/or shadows;" or would mysteriously "disappear" from the imagery when "carefully analyzed by experts." Like the human intelligence reports, not one of the priceless satellite images would be believed (See An Enormous Crime, Chapter 31).

Throughout it all, Sedgwick (Wick) Tourison, the DIA analyst with the uncanny ability to morph American POWs into Amerasian buffalo boys and ARVNs and Ministry of Interior prisons into cemeteries and/or hotels - or whatever else he, Destatte, Trowbridge and the others decided to morph American POWs and the prisons they were detained in into on a given day - continued to play a critical role. After retiring from the Special Office in 1988, Tourison penned his memoirs, entitled Talking with Victor Charlie. In the book, which was published in 1991, Tourison declared, "I was satisfied [after leaving the Special Office in 1988] that there were no live United States POWs in Southeast Asia and that there hadn't been any since Operation Homecoming in early 1973." 204 Shortly after the book was released, Tourison joined the staff of Sen. John Kerry’s Senate Select Committee on POW/MIA Affairs. He played a key role in the committee’s investigation and was a major author of the committee’s final report. (See An Enormous Crime, Chapters 29-32)

[back to supplemental material] [endnotes]Home